Chris Lester scored with three seconds left to give Monticello a 54-53 victory over Burgin on Saturday.
Host Burgin (10-14), which beat Monticello (4-18) in four overtimes in December, took a 53-52 lead on Sean Bottoms' 3-pointer with 35 seconds left.
The Trojans called timeout and held the ball for the final shot by Lester, who scored from 5 feet while being double-teamed. Burgin called timeout but didn't get off a final shot.
Zack Gross and Sean Bottoms had 12 points each and Bobby Wylie had 10 for Burgin, which shot 35.5 percent (16-for-45) and had only 10 turn-overs. Wylie had eight rebounds, while Gross had four assists.