Advertisement

Christian values and the Republican Party

June 28, 2005

Dear Editor:

Last Tuesday, your editorial page featured an essay by B. Russell Harper of Christian Care Communities. Harper urged us to protest massive cuts to the Medicaid budget looming in Congress and in the Kentucky legislature. He asked us to "demand that (government) place a top priority on covering basic health care" for those unable to afford it.

I noted the word "Christian" in the name of his organization, and thought to myself how appropriate it was for a Christian to make this appeal. When a scribe asked Jesus what was the greatest commandment, he answered that there were two: Love God with all your heart, and love your neighbor as yourself. "There is no other commandment greater than these." I thought that in a prosperous nation like ours, sincere Christians would insist that medical care be affordable for everyone.

All this leaves me puzzled about the strong link so many Americans see between Christian values and the Republican Party. Both Governor Fletcher and President Bush have taken Grover Norquist's pledge not to raise taxes, and to veto tax increases. This pledge is irresponsible, since it comes after a period of tax cuts that threaten basic services. It says that no need can be great enough to justify a tax increase, even if the alternative is to let people die from untreated illnesses. How could a Christian justify such a pledge?

Advertisement

Because of his pledge, Fletcher had to keep his tax reform plan "revenue neutral." So he offset the increase in cigarette and other retail taxes with substantial cuts in corporate taxes. These cuts will make it impossible to adequately fund education and health-care needs. He justified these tax cuts by claiming they would bring jobs to Kentucky, benefitting everyone.

Numerous studies have shown such claims to be false. As Republican Gov. Kenny Guinn of Nevada, a former banker and CEO, recently said, "I talk to a lot of CEOs when they are searching for a place to put the new factory. They don't look at taxes. The first thing they look at is your schools, your highways, the quality of living your state offers. If you want to attract business, you've got to provide that quality education. Well, you've got to have some tax revenue to pay for it. Business people understand that."

Fletcher doesn't.

Brian Cooney

Danville

Central Kentucky News Articles
|
|
|